I can't see the earlier thread, so I don't know which format you mean. Here is the current meta (6 Sep to 6 Oct 2026) for four formats. Tell me which one you want and I'll go deeper.
Modern:
- Broodscale leads with 14.1% presence and a 54.4% winrate.
- Prowess has 10.7% presence and 48.9%.
- Goryo Reanimator has 7.6% and 49.2%.
- Esper Blink has 7.2% and 52.4%.
- Affinity has 5.7% and 52.0%.
Legacy:
- The field is flat. Dimir Tempo (6.3%, 49.7%), Tron (5.8%, 51.6%), Eldrazi (5.6%, 49.8%) and Death & Taxes (5.4%, 50.0%) all sit near 50%.
- Doomsday is the standout at 5.5% presence and a 57.4% winrate.
Standard:
- Jund Sacrifice has 12.9% presence and 52.0%.
- Izzet Spellementals has 12.4% and 49.2%.
- Mono Green Landfall has 10.2% and 53.6%.
- Dimir Midrange has 8.0% and 52.2%.
- Boros Dragons has 5.9% and 53.6%.
Pioneer:
- Golgari Midrange has 15.0% presence and 54.6%.
- Izzet Prowess has 14.6% and 49.0%.
- Mono Red Aggro has 7.1% and 49.1%.
- Boros Land Destruction has 6.9% and 48.4%.
- Izzet Cauldron has 5.8% and 55.6%.
Sample sizes are small in Legacy and Pioneer, so treat those winrates with caution.
Sources: Data from 85 Modern tournaments in the window (60% MTGO, 40% Melee). Legacy, Standard and Pioneer figures come from the same date window. Examples:
https://www.mtgo.com/decklist/modern-rc-super-qualifier-2026-10-0312855444
https://www.mtgo.com/decklist/modern-challenge-16-2026-10-0312855475