← Back to Sessions

Broodscale Unholy Heat vs Dismember Weekly Ratio

1 requestsStarted 9/22/2026, 5:31:45 PM
can you share the ratio over time on a weekly base for the last 8 weeks (in %) between Broodscale playing unholy heat in the 75 and Broodscale playing dismember in the 75. Sum equal 100%. Exclude all lists who either are playing both or none of them. For each, please share the WR ratio over time in the same table.

Good, I have all IDs. Now let me run the weekly query for the last 8 weeks.

🛠️QueryWeekly card inclusion and win rate comparison

Here's the weekly breakdown — Unholy Heat vs Dismember in Broodscale 75s (excluding lists running both or neither):

⚠️ Note: week of Sep 15 is partial (data through Sep 21), and early weeks have low sample sizes.

WeekHeat %Heat WRDis %Dis WRN
Jul 28 – Aug 0356.0%44.4%44.0%51.1%25
Aug 04 – Aug 1058.8%36.4%41.2%67.3%34
Aug 11 – Aug 1744.0%59.5%56.0%45.0%25
Aug 18 – Aug 2425.9%50.0%74.1%39.5%27
Aug 25 – Aug 3128.2%58.7%71.8%52.5%71
Sep 01 – Sep 0729.0%53.1%71.0%55.7%138
Sep 08 – Sep 1412.4%47.7%87.6%56.5%492
Sep 15 – Sep 211.4%50.0%98.6%51.9%69

Key Takeaways:

  • 📉 Unholy Heat has been almost completely phased out — from ~57% share in early August to just 1.4% this week.
  • 📈 Dismember now dominates at ~98.6% adoption, a clear community consensus shift.
  • ⚔️ WR-wise, Dismember has been more consistent recently (55–57% WR over large samples in Sep 8–14). Heat's WR fluctuates more, likely due to smaller sample sizes skewing results.
  • The crossover point happened around Aug 18, when Dismember crossed 74% share and never looked back.

Sources: Data from 153 tournaments (64.7% MTGO, 35.3% Melee) · https://www.mtgo.com/decklist/modern-challenge-96-2026-09-2112854525 · https://www.mtgo.com/decklist/modern-challenge-64-2026-09-1912854505