Good - the top 10 are: Broodscale, Prowess, Goryo Reanimator, Esper Blink, Affinity, Devoted Combo, Tron, Boros Energy, Fight Rigging Eldrazi, Dimir Frog. Domain Zoo is #16, so I need to include it. Now I need to get all matchup winrates for these 11 archetypes against each other. That's 55 unique matchup pairs. Let me fire them all off.
Here is the full matchup winrate spreadsheet for the top 10 most popular Modern decks plus Domain Zoo (which came in at #16), covering the last 60 days of competitive data. All figures are winrate % for the ROW deck vs the COLUMN deck, mirror matches excluded. A dash (-) marks the diagonal.
Abbreviations used:
BSC = Broodscale | PRW = Prowess | GRY = Goryo Reanimator | ESP = Esper Blink | AFF = Affinity | DEV = Devoted Combo | TRN = Tron | BRE = Boros Energy | FRE = Fight Rigging Eldrazi | DMF = Dimir Frog | DZO = Domain Zoo
BSC PRW GRY ESP AFF DEV TRN BRE FRE DMF DZO
BSC - 52.6 55.0 52.7 62.3 41.9 59.9 46.4 47.6 60.7 51.1
PRW 47.4 - 45.4 48.9 41.8 66.8 41.4 57.9 41.5 52.3 44.9
GRY 45.0 54.6 - 38.8 40.1 49.3 40.0 50.0 52.8 45.6 54.6
ESP 47.3 51.1 61.2 - 46.7 69.3 44.5 50.8 56.1 64.6 65.8
AFF 37.7 58.2 59.9 53.3 - 35.3 57.8 60.0 35.6 64.1 44.4
DEV 58.1 33.2 50.8 30.7 64.7 - 63.1 50.0 72.4 53.9 65.8
TRN 40.1 58.7 60.0 55.5 42.2 36.9 - 38.4 31.3 54.2 42.0
BRE 53.7 42.1 50.0 49.3 40.0 50.0 61.6 - 53.3 41.7 63.2
FRE 52.4 58.5 47.2 43.9 64.4 27.6 68.8 46.7 - 51.6 47.5
DMF 39.3 47.7 54.4 35.4 35.9 46.2 45.8 58.3 48.4 - 51.5
DZO 48.9 55.1 45.4 34.3 55.6 34.2 58.0 36.8 52.5 48.5 -
Meta context (last 60 days): Broodscale leads meta share at 10.85% and posts a positive winrate in 8 of 10 matchups shown — its two weak spots are Devoted Combo (41.9%) and Boros Energy (46.4%). Devoted Combo is the most "polarizing" deck with several extreme edges: it dominates Fight Rigging Eldrazi (72.4%), Esper Blink (69.3%), and Domain Zoo (65.8%), but gets crushed by Prowess (33.2%) and Affinity (35.3%). Esper Blink is quietly one of the best-positioned decks — it beats Devoted Combo (69.3%), Dimir Frog (64.6%), Domain Zoo (65.8%), and Goryo Reanimator (61.2%). Domain Zoo (not in top 10 at 2.33% meta share) has a noticeably losing record against Esper Blink (34.3%), Devoted Combo (34.2%), and Boros Energy (36.8%).
Note: Some matchup samples are smaller (especially involving Domain Zoo), so treat those numbers with more variance in mind. Figures with fewer than ~50 decisive matches should be read directionally rather than as precise rates.
Sources: Data from 166 Modern tournaments (Jul 29 - Sep 28, 2026), 64.5% MTGO / 35.5% Melee.
https://www.mtgo.com/decklist/modern-challenge-64-2026-09-2612854922
https://www.mtgo.com/decklist/modern-challenge-16-2026-09-2612854917
https://www.mtgo.com/decklist/modern-challenge-64-2026-09-2612854916